Rise in Asylum Claims by International Students in Canada
Canada has announced a rise in asylum claims between January and September of this year to reach nearly 14,000 claims. Previously the asylum claims reached 12,000 as a maximum by 2023, which was a great raise after 2018 as it was just 1,810 claims. This rise has raised questions about the country’s immigration system and sparked concerns about possible misuse of asylum pathways.
Marc Miller, the Immigration Minister, pointed out possible problems in the case of some students being directed by external consultants to make fake asylum applications. Marc Miller has demanded changes and a probe that would set things right and ensure Canada’s immigration process is credible.
Why are Claims Increasing?
The increase in asylum applications results from the existing loopholes within the system and the increased presence of temporary residents in Canada. Many students seem to exploit these loopholes since they often claim asylum when there has not been any substantial change in their country of origin.
Such claims have been debunked by Minister Miller who referred to most of them as “largely false” and questioned their credibility. “It is quite obvious someone that’s been here a year or more, claiming asylum where no conditions have changed in their home country – it doesn’t smell good, it doesn’t look good,” Miller stated.
Reports also point to the role of some immigration consultants who charge international students high fees, sometimes upwards of $7,000, for helping them file asylum claims. These consultants might promise that a legal work authorization will be issued during the processing period, allowing the students to stay and work in Canada for an extended time.
Find out if you are eligible to get in Canada →
Key Statistics Regarding This Rise
The following colleges in Canada have reported the most significant number of asylum claims this year:
- Conestoga College: 520 claims
- Seneca College: 490 claims
- Niagara College: 410 claims
Most of those claims are from students whose origins are in India, Nigeria, Ghana, Guinea, and the Democratic Republic of Congo. It follows from this trend that certain regions seem to be abusing asylum applications to prolong their stay in Canada.
Proposed Solutions
To address the issue, experts and policymakers have come up with some changes to avoid misusing the asylum system to include:
1. Limiting Claims for Expiring Permits
Students whose study or work permits are set to expire may be disallowed from applying for asylum. This would discourage people from using asylum as a last resort to stay in Canada.
2. Time Limits for Filing
New regulations may ask that asylum claims be filed within 24 hours of arrival in the country. In case of late filing, the application must report to official border entry points for processing.
3. Tighter Control at the Border Points
More personnel could be sent to the borders of Canada to more closely analyze the validity of asylum applications before allowing the claimants to enter the country.
Supporters of these claims believe that even if there is an additional cost for administration purposes, such measures must be put in place to maintain the credibility of the immigration system in Canada.
Investigating Immigration Consultants
Minister Miller has also been demanding accountability from immigration consultants who may be recommending false claims. He wrote to the College of Immigration and Citizenship Consultants (CICC), which licenses such consultants, to ask that it investigate those who advise students to submit misleading information.
He noted that such actions violate the ethical standards outlined in the Code of Professional Conduct for Licensees. “I would like to raise an important and concerning issue of which I am sure you are aware: the growing number of international students claiming asylum in Canada. I am concerned about reports that some of these students are being counseled by third parties to do so and to provide false information.”
The minister urged the CICC to work closely with Immigration, Refugees, and Citizenship Canada to address this issue and remind consultants of their professional responsibilities.
Wider Impacts on Housing and Social Services
The asylum claims are being influenced by broader issues in Canada. This includes the increasing number of temporary residents, particularly international students, who are placing considerable strain on the country’s housing market and social services. False asylum claims have been criticized for exacerbating these problems and stealing resources from bona fide refugees and vulnerable groups.
“Students filing false claims are not just gaming the system; they’re adding to the challenges faced by local communities,” said a spokesperson for a Canadian immigration watchdog.
Public opinion on the matter is highly divided. Some Canadians express empathy for international students with uncertain futures, while others demand stricter regulations to ensure no loopholes or system abuse are present.
Balancing Fairness and Protection
While the federal government fiddles Herculean with untangling this knotty problem, Minister Miller has found a delicate balance between Canada’s humanitarian obligations and protections against exploitation.
The asylum system is there to protect people running away from various kinds of danger, and their misuse denies its very purpose. With proposed reforms and continuing investigations, Canada has taken steps to restore trust in accountability for its immigration pathways.
For the time being, the record number of asylum claims only emphasizes the urgent need for clear rules and enforcement. Canada needs to make sure its systems remain fair and accessible to the truly needy, yet guarded against those who would exploit its generosity.
The increasing asylum requests filed by international students indicate certain ailments of the Canadian immigration system. Although Canada intends to offer protection to truly needy individuals, its misapplication makes it pretty hard to achieve that purpose. To this end, the government is seeking projects under new legislation that will hold immigration consultants accountable for their actions. This is a step meant to protect and maintain the integrity of the system. By clarifying support for genuine refugees as opposed to stronger controls, Canada would make sure that the immigration process remains fair and honest for everyone.
